Let’s talk about the ultimate Hermès debate—Birkin vs. Kelly! Now, full disclosure: I currently own a Birkin 25, but I’ve had the chance to see and experience the Kelly in person. While I haven’t added a Kelly to my collection yet, I’ve done tons of research, tried them out in-store, and talked to other collectors. So, here’s my personal take on how these two bags compare—no fluff, just real talk!
When it comes to luxury handbags, Hermès reigns at the top, and two of its most coveted bags, the Birkin and Kelly are the ultimate symbols of status, elegance, and exclusivity. But which one is right for you? Let’s break it down!
Design & Structure
Birkin
Open-top tote with two handles, giving it a relaxed and casual vibe. No strap.
Kelly
Structured, more formal, with a single top handle and a detachable strap for versatility.
Closure System
Birkin
Flap closure, but usually carried open for quick access.
Kelly
Must be closed with a turn-lock to maintain its signature structured shape.
Sizes & Wearability
Birkin
- 25 cm: Compact and Trendy. Can be worn from day to night.
- 30 cm: Most popular, versatile. Great for everyday wear.
- 35 cm: Spacious, slightly less in demand. Great for work and travel.
- 40 cm: Oversized, travel friendly. Such a statement piece and perfect for traveling.
- It lacks a strap, so it’s hand-carry only.
Kelly
- 20 cm: Mini Bag, great for evening. (more an accessory than an actual bag)
- 25 cm: More structured than the Birkin (specially in the Sellier style). Very classic and elegant.
- 28 cm: Offers a balance between elegance and practicality.
- 32 cm: Provides ample space without feeling oversized.
- It includes a crossbody strap, making it more practical for hands-free use.
Curated by Lena
Rarity & Availability
Birkin
Hard to get, but larger sizes (35, 40) can sometimes be easier to find than smaller sizes (25, 30).
Kelly
Mini Kelly (20) is among the hardest to acquire and is sometimes even rarer than a Birkin 25.
Investment & Resale Value
If you’re thinking about long-term value, the Mini Kelly (20 cm) and Birkin 25 in neutral colors or exotic leathers have the highest resale potential. Also limited editions (like the Kelly in Sellier or Special-Order Birkins tend to appreciate significantly with time.
Final Verdict: Which One to Choose?
When selecting a Hermès Birkin or Kelly, size plays a major role in both function and style. Whether you’re looking for a compact statement bag or a spacious everyday companion, here’s how to choose the perfect size
- For Everyday use: → Birkin 25, 30 or Kelly 25, 28
- For Elegance & Versatility: → Mini Kelly (20 cm), 25 (especially Sellier style)
- For Investment & Resale: → Mini Kelly (20 cm) or Birkin 25
- For Travel & Larger carry: → Birkin 35+ or Kelly 32
It truly depends on your style and lifestyle. If you love a casual-chic tote that’s easy to access, go for the Birkin. If you prefer a structured-elegant handbag that can be worn crossbody, the Kelly is your best bet.
at seamlessly fits into your world.
Both bags are iconic, investment-worthy pieces that elevate any wardrobe. Whether you’re drawn to the chic versatility of a Birkin and Kelly 25 , the everyday luxury of a Birkin 30 or Kelly 28, or the bold statement of a Birkin 40, your ideal Hermès bag is the one that seamlessly fits into your world.
No matter which you choose, one thing is certain—both the Birkin and Kelly are forever classics that will stand the test of time.
